| Platinum | Meltz Extreme Grilled Cheese |
| Gold | Gandolfo's New York Deli |
| Silver | San Francisco Style Sourdough Eatery |
| Bronze | Cafe Zupas |
| Bronze | Hugos Deli |
| Top Pick | Earl of Sandwich |
| Top Pick | Gyro Shack |
| Top Pick | Idaho Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Papa Kelsey's |
| Top Pick | Soup Kettle Grille |